Is character arc or character development more important (assuming they are in conflict?)

Introduction: Definitions and Context

When it comes to character development in storytelling, two terms that often come up are “character arc” and “character development”. Although they are related concepts, they can create a conflict when trying to decide which is more important. Character development refers to the process of creating a rounded, believable character over the course of a story. This involves not only exploring a character’s personality and backstory, but also how they react to plot events and how they develop emotionally as the story progresses.

On the other hand, a character arc refers to the specific transformation or change a character undergoes during the course of the story. This may involve overcoming obstacles, learning from mistakes, or resolving inner conflicts. Although character development and character arc are often related, they can sometimes be at odds with each other. For example, character development may require a character to behave in a way that is inconsistent with the arc the writer is trying to create.

So the question arises: which is more important, character arc or character development? In this article, we will explore this question in more depth, highlighting the nuances of each concept and the factors that can influence their relative importance in storytelling.

The Importance of Character Development

In storytelling, character development is a crucial element that can make or break a narrative. It is the process of creating a realistic and multidimensional character who evolves over the course of the story, often through the character arc. The character arc is the path the character takes in response to the events of the story and the challenges they face.

When it comes to the debate between character arc and character development, both are important, but character development plays a more significant role. While a character arc can be compelling, a well-developed character can add depth and complexity to the story.

Character development is important because it allows the audience to relate to and understand the character’s motivations, desires and flaws. It’s what makes them feel like real people, not just fictional creations. When done well, character development can evoke emotional responses and create a sense of empathy, which can lead to a more satisfying and impactful resolution.

In addition, character development can add thematic depth to a story by exploring complex ideas and universal truths through the lens of a particular character. By examining a character’s struggles and growth, a story can provide insights into the human experience and offer lessons or insights that resonate with the audience.

The Importance of Character Arc

Storytelling is about creating compelling characters and bringing them to life through their arcs. Character arc refers to the way in which a character develops and changes over the course of the story. It is a crucial element of storytelling because it determines the degree to which the audience can relate to and engage with the character.

In many ways, character arc and character development go hand in hand. Character development refers to the way a character is established and portrayed in a story. But a well-crafted character arc takes character development to the next level, showing how the character’s experiences and actions shape who they are and how they interact with the world around them.

A strong character arc serves several important functions in storytelling. Firstly, it helps to create a sense of emotional depth and complexity in the characters. By allowing the audience to see the character change and grow, the arc creates a deeper sense of investment in the character’s fate and the outcome of the story.

In addition, a well-crafted character arc can help convey the story’s themes and messages more effectively. By showing how the character changes and evolves in response to the challenges he or she faces, the arc can provide a more nuanced and layered exploration of the story’s central ideas.

Balancing Character Development and Character Arc

When it comes to creating compelling characters in fiction, both character development and character arc play an important role. However, when these two aspects of character creation conflict, it can be difficult to strike a balance between them.

Character development is the process of creating an individual character with a unique personality, backstory, motivations and flaws. Character development can be seen as the foundation of a story’s characters, as it allows them to feel real, relatable and engaging to the audience. It’s about creating well-rounded, fleshed-out individuals with whom the reader can connect emotionally.

The character arc, on the other hand, refers to the journey the character takes throughout the story. In other words, it’s how the character changes or grows as a result of the events that take place. It’s the character’s progression from point A to point B, and it includes both their internal and external struggles. The character arc is what gives the story its emotional impact and serves as the backbone of the plot.

In some cases, character development and character arc can be at odds with each other. For example, if a character is well developed at the start of the story, it can be a challenge to create a significant arc that feels earned rather than forced. Alternatively, if a character has a lot of room to grow, it can be tempting to focus solely on their arc and neglect their development as an individual.

To strike a balance between character development and character arc, it’s important to see the two as interconnected rather than separate. Character development can inform their arc, and their arc can inform their development. It’s a delicate dance between shaping a character in a way that feels realistic and fulfilling, and giving them enough arcs to make the story compelling.

Ultimately, the key is to ensure that the character’s arc feels authentic and earned.

Case Studies: Examples of Stories That Emphasize Development vs. Arc

  1. The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger: This novel emphasises the character development of its protagonist, Holden Caulfield, as he struggles with issues of identity and alienation. While there is a loose arc to the narrative, with Holden exploring various options for self-discovery (e.g. leaving prep school, interacting with various characters, etc.), the primary focus is on his emotional growth and coming to terms with the complexities of the adult world.
  2. Breaking Bad: This TV series is a good example of a story that emphasises the character arc. While the protagonist, Walter White, undergoes some character development over the course of the series (e.g., becoming more ruthless and willing to engage in criminal activity), the core of the show focuses on his evolution from a meek and mild-mannered high school teacher to a ruthless drug lord. This narrative arc is what drives the show’s tension and suspense, rather than a particular focus on character development for its own sake.
  3. To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee: Like The Catcher in the Rye, this novel emphasises character development over arc. Through the eyes of its protagonist, Scout Finch, the novel explores social justice, racial inequality and moral growth. While there is a vague arc to the story (focusing on the trial of a black man for a crime he did not commit), the emphasis is on the moral and social growth that Scout experiences as she comes to understand the complexities of her world.

These are just a few examples, but they should give you an idea of how stories can be structured around either character development or arc, depending on the emphasis of the narrative. Ultimately, the right approach will depend on the writer’s goals and the needs of the story they are trying to tell.

Conclusion: The Importance of Considering Both Elements

In the debate between character arc and character development, it is important to consider both elements when creating a compelling and effective story. While character arc focuses on the transformation of a character over the course of a narrative, character development offers a more holistic approach that includes factors such as backstory, motivation, and personality traits.

The best stories feature characters who are dynamic, complex and relatable, and the interplay between character arc and character development is essential to achieving these goals. By focusing on both elements, writers can create characters that are not only interesting and multidimensional, but also resonate with the audience on a deeper level.

Ultimately, both character arc and character development are crucial components of effective storytelling, and writers must learn to balance and blend these elements to achieve their desired effects. In doing so, they can create narratives that are both entertaining and meaningful, and that leave a lasting impact on the reader or viewer.

Additional Considerations: Genre, Audience, and Story Goals

Genre, audience and story goals are crucial aspects to consider when examining the importance of character arc vs. character development in a story. The genre of a story can strongly influence the importance of character arc or character development. For example, in an action-oriented story, a strong character arc may be more important than character development.

Similarly, the audience should be considered when deciding how much emphasis to place on character arc or development. If the audience consists of young children or newcomers to a genre, character development may be more important because they need to be introduced to the characters in order to engage with the story. However, if the audience is more experienced, a strong character arc may be the way to go.

The story’s aims must also be considered when deciding between character arc and character development. If the primary goal of the story is to show a character’s transformation, then a strong character arc should be the focus. On the other hand, if the goal of the story is to establish a rich and complex character with a deep backstory, then character development should be the focus. Ultimately, every story is unique, and these additional considerations must be carefully weighed when determining the importance of arc or development in a given story.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *